Esmeralda Upton, 59, was found guilty of a racially motivated assault on four friends outside Sixty Vines in August 2022. This case is unusual in that it involves a hate crime enhancement. Collin County District Attorney Greg Willis emphasized the significance of the conviction, stating that while misdemeanor assault charges are not uncommon, it is rare to see hate crime enhancements.
Details of the Incident
This Article Includes
As they were leaving Sixty Vines one summer evening, four friends came across Upton who was making racially insensitive remarks. One of the friends decided to record the incident while another called 911, but the situation quickly turned violent. Three of the women were physically assaulted, and the fourth was threatened.
The Conviction Process
As I observed the courtroom proceedings, I gained valuable insights into the dynamics at play. Willis shared that Upton did not testify since the case was resolved through an agreed plea. However, the women were given the opportunity to deliver their victim impact statement, which was a significant moment.
Victims’ Impact Statements
The victim impact statements were deeply moving and had a lasting impact. Willis was touched by the strength of those who spoke, saying, “During the victim impact, they shared how the traumatic experience had left them with anxiety in open spaces. Despite this, they demonstrated remarkable resilience. I am incredibly proud of each of our brave victims and the incredible progress they have made.”
Law Enforcement and Community Reaction
Law enforcement officials and the local community have been reacting strongly to this case, with differing opinions on the relatively uncommon use of hate crime enhancements in such situations.
